The Newman Blog

Who is At Fault for a Collision in a Parking Lot?

Woman on cell phone beside man writing on paper exchanging insurance information after an accident
By:
Economical Insurance
|
Economical Insurance
|
August 11, 2020

Even though the basic rules of the road still apply when you’re driving in a parking lot, it may be a little more difficult to figure out who is at fault for an accident. Being considered “at fault” for a collision could play a role in determining whether or not you have to pay your deductible when you make a claim, and it could also affect your car insurance premium. While fault determination rules vary by province, here are some examples of common accidents that occur in parking lots and how fault may be determined in each scenario.

Who is at fault if your car is hit while it’s parked?

If your vehicle is hit while it’s legally parked and you’re able to identify the other driver, you probably won’t be considered at fault. But if you’re opening your door and another driver hits it while it’s open, you would likely be considered at fault. While liability for parked-car collisions can vary by situation, your insurer will do their best to avoid considering you at fault whenever possible.

Who is at fault if you get hit while pulling out of a parking spot?

If you hit another vehicle or another vehicle hits you while you’re leaving a parking spot and entering the feeder lane (the lane you’d be pulling into from your parking spot), you will likely be considered at fault, as vehicles in the feeder lane always have the right of way. Always look both ways as you leave a parking spot to avoid getting involved in an at-fault collision.

Who is at fault when two vehicles exiting parking spots hit each other at the same time?

In this situation, the fault could be split 50/50, but the rules vary slightly by provincially legislated rules. Typically, fault would be split 50/50 when your insurer is unable to determine who is at fault based on the details of the accident, or if two cars hit each other at the same time while they are both leaving their parking spots.

Who is at fault when you get into a collision in a thoroughfare?

After you leave your parking spot and drive to the end of the feeder lane, you end up pulling into a thoroughfare, or a main “road” inside the parking lot. Vehicles driving in the thoroughfare always have the right of way. If you hit another vehicle while you’re turning into a thoroughfare, you will be considered at fault.

Who is at fault in a hit-and-run collision?

If you find that your vehicle has been damaged by another vehicle in a hit-and-run, most insurers will require you to report it to the police within 24 hours in order for them to consider it a not-at-fault accident.  If you fail to report the collision to police within the timeframe required by your insurer, you could be considered at fault by your insurer.

While these are a few common scenarios and examples of how fault may be determined after a parking lot collision, there are many factors and rules that go into determining who is at fault, and they vary by province. Generally speaking, in provinces (such as Ontario) that follow a “no-fault” or Direct Compensation Property Damage (DCPD) system, fault for a collision will be determined based on specific fault determination rules. In provinces without DCPD systems, fault will be determined based on the provincial rules of the road. 

If you have questions about a specific situation, it’s best to give us a call. 

The content in this article is for information purposes only and is not intended to be relied upon as professional or expert advice.
This article was originally posted on

Read more posts

Filtering by: 
Tag
click to clear this filter
Which Windshield Washer Fluid Should You Use?

Which Windshield Washer Fluid Should You Use?

Not all washer fluids are created equal. Some formulas are better for melting snow and ice, while others tackle bugs, dirt, and tar. Get to know your options before topping up your washer tank.

Read post
5 Things You Need To Know About Home-Based Business Insurance

5 Things You Need To Know About Home-Based Business Insurance

Insurance might not be top of mind when planning a home-based business. Here are the top five things you need to know to protect yourself and your home.

Read post
What Happens When Your Vehicle Is A Total Loss?

What Happens When Your Vehicle Is A Total Loss?

Even when there are no injuries, the aftermath of a car accident can be stressful. Here are the answers to some questions you might be asking after your car has been declared a total loss.

Read post
Insurance Tips For Newlyweds

Insurance Tips For Newlyweds

Whether you've lived with your new spouse for years or you've just moved into your first home together, make sure you've checked these to-dos off your list.

Read post
Should You Increase Your Loss of Use Coverage?

Should You Increase Your Loss of Use Coverage?

Loss of use or transportation replacement coverage helps cover the cost of alternate transportation if your vehicle is involved in a covered claim. It is an important additional insurance coverage that many people neglect to carry.

Read post
Carjacking: How To Protect Yourself

Carjacking: How To Protect Yourself

Across Canada, rates of reported carjackings are rising. Stay diligent and take extra measures to protect yourself, when parked and when on the road by knowing what puts you at greater risk of experiencing a carjacking.

Read post
What Happens If Your Property Is Underinsured?

What Happens If Your Property Is Underinsured?

To avoid being underinsured is to be certain that you are appropriately covered for your home and your contents.

Read post
7 Water Safety Tips For The Summer

7 Water Safety Tips For The Summer

Whether you're headed up to the cottage or planning a pool party, knowing some basic water safety tips can help keep you and your fellow swimmers out of trouble.

Read post
Learn How To Protect Yourself From Vehicle Theft

Learn How To Protect Yourself From Vehicle Theft

In 2021, losses stemming from vehicle theft rose over 20% from the previous year. While vehicle thefts have increased, there are fewer vehicles that are being recovered after they’ve been stolen.

Read post
How To Prevent Fires On Your Property

How To Prevent Fires On Your Property

There's no place like home — so it makes sense to protect yours as best you can. Safeguarding your home against fire is a good place to start, but it's important to do the same for the rest of your property, including your yard.

Read post
Tree Maintenance and Care

Tree Maintenance and Care

The trees in your yard can enhance your property, provide shade and offer abundant environmental benefits. However, trees can also pose a safety hazard to your family and your home if they are not properly inspected and maintained.

Read post
What Is CAA MyPace™ - Pay-As-You-Go Insurance?

What Is CAA MyPace™ - Pay-As-You-Go Insurance?

There are many options out there for auto insurance. One option that you may not be aware of is the CAA MyPace, a pay-as-you-go insurance payment program.

Read post
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Get the right insurance

Tell us what's important to you.
We'll help you get the right insurance at the right price.

Or call 1-800-653-1924