The Newman Blog

What Happens When Your Vehicle Is A Total Loss?

crushed cars piled up in junkyard
By:
Jeannette Cantin
|
Economical Insurance
|
September 22, 2022

Even when there are no injuries, the aftermath of a car accident can be stressful. Realizing your vehicle is a total loss on top of it all might seem overwhelming. Here are the answers to some questions you might be asking after your car has been declared a total loss.

What does "total loss" mean in car insurance?

The terms "write off," "total loss," and "totaled car" have the same meaning in the insurance world — your car is either damaged beyond repair, or the cost to repair the damage would be greater than the value of your vehicle.

Will my car insurance protect me if my vehicle is totaled?

The short answer is yes — your insurance policy will cover your damages, including a total loss, when the cause of the loss is covered under your policy. Generally speaking, a car insurance policy with collision and comprehensive coverage will provide coverage for a wide variety of scenarios, such as traffic accidents, collisions with animals, and non-collision events like theft, fallen trees, or weather damage. Any of these situations could result in a total loss, in which case your policy would cover the value of your car. If you have coverage for transportation replacement, your insurance will also cover the cost of rental vehicle.

There are some scenarios where your car insurance policy might not provide coverage. The circumstances of the accident might breach policy terms, such as driving while impaired, for example. And if you only have collision coverage, you won't be covered for damage caused by events like weather or vandalism, which typically require comprehensive or all-perils coverage. Every policy is unique and has its own limits and terms, so be sure to review your own policy documents and ask your broker if you have any questions about your coverage.

How will my insurance company determine the value of my vehicle if it's a total loss?

There are two common calculations used to determine the amount you will get for your vehicle in the event of a total loss. Replacement cost only applies if you have purchased a depreciation waiver endorsement (typically only available on brand new vehicles for a limited time). You'll be covered for the lower amount of the manufacturer's suggested retail price (MSRP) or the original purchase price, depending on the terms of your waiver. Otherwise, you'll receive the actual cash value, which factors in depreciation. Depreciation varies, but generally speaking, your insurer will review the market value in your area for similar vehicles and base your claim payout on your vehicle's age, mileage, and wear and tear.

What if my leased or financed vehicle is a total loss?

Whether you lease, finance, or own your car, the claims process is similar. If you lease your car, your insurer will settle the loss with the owner of the vehicle: the leasing company. You may owe more to a leasing or financing company than the actual value of your car. If that's the case, you're still required to pay the difference between the settlement and what you owe. As previously mentioned, a depreciation waiver can help offset this, although there are situations — if the manufacturer's suggested retail price is lower than your purchase price, or the cost of borrowing is high, for example — where you may still have a shortfall. You are still responsible for paying the amount owed, even though you no longer have use of the vehicle.

What if I disagree with my car insurance payout after my vehicle is totaled?

If you believe your claim payout seems lower than it should be, it's a good idea to do your own research of the marketplace to get a realistic idea of the value of similar vehicles (make and model, age, mileage). If you've done so and still believe the settlement amount is unfair, the first course of action is to speak to your adjuster. Make sure there is no misunderstanding of the calculation before you escalate the issue. If you're still not satisfied, your adjuster will provide you information about the dispute process available to you under the Insurance Act.

When do I get my new vehicle after a car insurance claim?

When your vehicle has been declared a total loss, your insurance company will pay your claim settlement amount directly to you. This is also the case if your car is financed, but the finance company is also named on the cheque (co-payable). If you lease your vehicle, the leasing company will receive the co-payable cheque directly, and they will give you the difference if the settlement is more than you currently owe.

You're responsible for finding and purchasing a new vehicle yourself. The price you pay for the replacement vehicle, whether it's more or less than your settlement, is up to you as well. Keep in mind that current supply chain disruption issues may affect the cost and timing of getting a new vehicle. If you decide to purchase a used car instead, consider the factors that may affect your car insurance. Some vehicle modifications, for example, may not be eligible for coverage. Talk to your broker before you make your purchase to find out if there are insurance implications.

How long will it take to receive my car insurance claim payout after my vehicle is totaled?

The length of time between filing your claim and receiving a settlement for your vehicle will vary depending on your insurer and the circumstances of your claim, but generally speaking, a straightforward claim can typically be settled in two or three weeks.

Will my car insurance premium increase after a total loss claim?

Possibly, but this depends largely on whether you were at fault for the collision. There are several reasons why your car insurance costs may increase, and involvement in an at-fault collision is one of them. Many insurance companies include accident forgiveness in their policies, which may protect you from a rate increase after your first at-fault accident. If you're not at fault, the claim likely won't affect your premium.

If it's been a while since you've reviewed your car insurance coverage, it's a good idea to review your policy with your broker to make sure you have the coverage you need to protect you in the event of a total loss. If you're in an accident and your car is damaged or totaled, be sure to file your claim as soon as possible.

The content in this article is for information purposes only and is not intended to be relied upon as professional or expert advice.
This article was originally posted on

Read more posts

Filtering by: 
Tag
click to clear this filter
Insurance Tips For Newlyweds

Insurance Tips For Newlyweds

Whether you've lived with your new spouse for years or you've just moved into your first home together, make sure you've checked these to-dos off your list.

Read post
Should You Increase Your Loss of Use Coverage?

Should You Increase Your Loss of Use Coverage?

Loss of use or transportation replacement coverage helps cover the cost of alternate transportation if your vehicle is involved in a covered claim. It is an important additional insurance coverage that many people neglect to carry.

Read post
Carjacking: How To Protect Yourself

Carjacking: How To Protect Yourself

Across Canada, rates of reported carjackings are rising. Stay diligent and take extra measures to protect yourself, when parked and when on the road by knowing what puts you at greater risk of experiencing a carjacking.

Read post
What Happens If Your Property Is Underinsured?

What Happens If Your Property Is Underinsured?

To avoid being underinsured is to be certain that you are appropriately covered for your home and your contents.

Read post
7 Water Safety Tips For The Summer

7 Water Safety Tips For The Summer

Whether you're headed up to the cottage or planning a pool party, knowing some basic water safety tips can help keep you and your fellow swimmers out of trouble.

Read post
Learn How To Protect Yourself From Vehicle Theft

Learn How To Protect Yourself From Vehicle Theft

In 2021, losses stemming from vehicle theft rose over 20% from the previous year. While vehicle thefts have increased, there are fewer vehicles that are being recovered after they’ve been stolen.

Read post
How To Prevent Fires On Your Property

How To Prevent Fires On Your Property

There's no place like home — so it makes sense to protect yours as best you can. Safeguarding your home against fire is a good place to start, but it's important to do the same for the rest of your property, including your yard.

Read post
Tree Maintenance and Care

Tree Maintenance and Care

The trees in your yard can enhance your property, provide shade and offer abundant environmental benefits. However, trees can also pose a safety hazard to your family and your home if they are not properly inspected and maintained.

Read post
What Is CAA MyPace™ - Pay-As-You-Go Insurance?

What Is CAA MyPace™ - Pay-As-You-Go Insurance?

There are many options out there for auto insurance. One option that you may not be aware of is the CAA MyPace, a pay-as-you-go insurance payment program.

Read post
5 little-known facts about seasonal property insurance

5 little-known facts about seasonal property insurance

When it comes to seasonal property insurance, it's about more than their physical differences. Take note of these five little-known facts about seasonal property insurance coverage and talk to your broker about what is (and what isn't) covered in your policy.

Read post
Save the Stress: Sump Pump Basics

Save the Stress: Sump Pump Basics

Understanding how your sump pump works and how to maintain it is an easy way to prevent water damage in your home. This post covers what a sump pump does and how to maintain it.

Read post
How to protect your car from catalytic converter theft

How to protect your car from catalytic converter theft

Cases of catalytic converter theft are increasing across Canada. Find out everything you need to know about catalytic converter theft and learn how to protect your car.

Read post
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Get the right insurance

Tell us what's important to you.
We'll help you get the right insurance at the right price.

Or call 1-800-653-1924