What’s the difference between replacement cost and actual cash value?

“Replacement cost” and “actual cash value” are two of the most common calculations insurers use to determine the amount a customer will receive if they make a home insurance claim or a car insurance claim. In other words, you could either be reimbursed for the cost to replace the lost or damaged item or its actual cash value, depending on what it says in your policy. So, what’s the difference? And how do these calculations really apply when you make a claim? Let’s take a look.

Replacement cost

If your policy says it will cover the replacement cost of an item that is lost or damaged, the dollar amount you’ll be paid is equal to the cost you’d need to replace that item with a new, similar product of like kind and quality. Since insurance is designed to get you back to the same position you were in just before a loss, your insurer will do some research and determine how much it would cost to replace the item with a new one that’s as comparable as possible — no more, no less.

Actual cash value

If your policy is set up to cover the actual cash value of an item that is lost or damaged, the dollar amount you’ll be paid is equal to how much the exact item would be worth today. This considers the original price you paid for the item, but it also considers depreciation (the natural decrease in an item’s value over time, usually due to wear and tear) and the physical condition the item was in on the day of the loss. Most insurance companies will use standard guidelines (known as “depreciation tables” in the insurance world) to determine an item’s actual cash value — or they’ll contact a professional retailer or appraiser to determine what a similar used item would cost to buy.

The premium you pay when you have an actual cash value policy may be lower since the reimbursement you’d receive in the event of a claim is generally much less than you’d receive with a replacement cost policy.

How do replacement cost and actual cash value work in real life?

Keep in mind that these examples are intended to give you a basic understanding of how actual cash value and replacement cost work. If you have specific questions about your own policy, speak to your insurance broker at Newman Insurance. 

Picture this: A pipe in your basement bursts and damages the sewing machine you purchased 30 years ago for $500. After consulting a professional sewing machine technician, your insurer informs you that the machine is damaged beyond repair. So, how much will you be reimbursed?

With replacement cost:

You’ll be reimbursed for the value of a new sewing machine of a like kind and quality to the one that was destroyed in the flood. In this case, you may be able to purchase a new sewing machine for around $800.

With actual cash value:

You’ll be reimbursed for the value of a similar 30-year-old sewing machine in the same condition as the one that was destroyed in the flood. In this case, you might receive around $80.

Picture this: A rear-end collision on your way home from work lands your two-year-old SUV in the shop. After receiving an estimate for the repairs, your insurer decides your vehicle isn’t worth repairing. How much will you be reimbursed?

With replacement cost:

While most car insurance policies only allow for actual cash value, some insurers may allow you to add special coverage to your policy that takes depreciation out of the equation. If this is part of your coverage, the dollar amount you’ll be paid is equal to the amount you’d need to replace your vehicle with a new, similar vehicle — no more, no less.

With actual cash value:

The dollar amount you’ll be paid to replace your two-year old SUV is equal to the amount the vehicle is worth today. To calculate your vehicle’s actual cash value (or the amount of money your vehicle is worth after depreciation), most insurers will research comparable vehicles on the market and will consider several factors, including age, kilometres, make and model, fuel economy, and wear and tear.

Reach out to us at Newman Insurance to learn how your own coverage works or find out how your deductibles might apply in situations like these. If you’re in the process of shopping for insurance, contact Newman Insurance at 1-800-653-1924 or contact us online.